Does 1 Timothy 2 ban women from teaching in Church?
In the turbulent debate over women’s ministry, 1 Timothy 2:12 is at the centre of the storm. According to the English Standard Version of the Bible, Paul writes: “I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man; rather, she is to remain quiet.”
In other places in the New Testament, Paul affirms women as teachers. So, what does he mean here? Is this some kind of general prohibition or is it specific to a particular situation?
The scholars’ discussion over this is enormous. My forthcoming book ‘True Complementarity’ has seven whole chapters on it. But we can get to the heart of the debate by asking five short questions.
Q1. Which women is Paul talking about – all women or some particular women in the church in Ephesus, the destination of the letter?
In chapter 2 verse 9, Paul speaks against women adorning themselves with pearls.
In the ancient world, pearls were not available as they are today; pearls were only for the super-rich. Paul wouldn’t waste his breath with instructions for women in general not to wear pearls. Most women would never have the slightest prospect of ever wearing a pearl.
This shows that Paul has in mind some super-rich women in Ephesus. We know it was a city where there were some very rich people.
From various clues in the letter, especially in the Greek of chapter 5, we can infer that these women are probably young widows who are recent converts. They have come from the cult of the goddess Artemis of the Ephesians. But they have been deceived by some false and immoral teachings within the church and they are each on the look-out for a man.
Q2. In verse 12 Paul’s governing expression is ‘I do not permit’ or ‘I am not permitting’. Why does he use this expression?
There is nowhere in the whole of the Bible where anyone uses this expression to state a general rule of conduct. It is not appropriate for prohibiting something that is against God’s revealed will and therefore sinful. Can you imagine a pastor saying to the flock: “I do not permit you to murder” or “I am not permitting you to commit adultery”? A pastor has no authority to permit or not permit what God has revealed to be wrong!
If God revealed that it was wrong for a woman to teach, a pastor would not say “I do not permit a woman to teach”. Paul doesn’t have authority to either permit or not permit something that is against God’s revealed will.
Paul’s choice of words – a personal withholding of permission – tells us that he is not referring to a general rule revealed by God but is dealing with a particular situation. His prohibition in verse 12 applies to the rich, deceived women that he has just been referring to in verses 9 and 10.
Q3. In verse 12, what is the true meaning of the Greek verb authenteō, which the ESV renders as ‘exercise authority’?
English versions offer more than 20 different translations of this word. The difficulty is that it’s a very rare word. This is its only occurrence in the Bible, and it’s rare in other Greek writings before or around Paul’s time.
The best evidence shows it to mean something like ‘dominate’, ‘lord it over’, ‘overpower’.
This is the meaning in the two best examples which we have from near Paul’s time. (One is an astrological text. The other is a letter about transport business on the Nile.)
This is also the meaning given in some of the very earliest versions which translated Paul’s letter into other languages, such as Syriac, Coptic, Gothic and Latin. In the Latin Vulgate, the word used by the translator is the same as in 1 Peter 5:3, where Peter forbids church elders to ‘lord it over’ the flock.
Some take Paul to mean that authoritative teaching is the job of a male church elder. But this Greek word is unsuitable for something that a church elder ought to do. It is something that an elder ought not to do!
Paul doesn’t want one of these deceived women overpowering a man with false teaching, leading him astray into misbehaviour.
In verses 13-14, Paul goes on to give reasons for his instructions. In the ESV: “For Adam was formed first, then Eve; and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor.” This leads us to–
Q4: What is the nature of Paul’s reasoning? Is he relying on a creation ordinance of male-over-female authority, or is he supporting his restriction with an apt Old Testament illustration where a woman was deceived by false teaching, with bad results?
Those who restrict women’s teaching rely centrally on their interpretation of verse 13. They believe Paul must be laying down a general rule about men and women because he refers to the creation story. Paul doesn’t actually say anything in these two verses about male authority, but they believe it is implied: where Paul says Adam was formed first, then Eve, this implies a creation ordinance of male-over-female authority.
But why should we imagine that to be implied here? Sequence of man, then woman, is not the same thing as authority of man over woman.
Many suggest that Paul is thinking of the ancient Hebrew custom of primogeniture – the special rights and authority of a firstborn son: Adam was first, so it is implied that he has special rights and authority over Eve.
But the Genesis text doesn’t point to that idea. It doesn’t refer to Adam as the firstborn. Nor does Paul. Nor does the Bible anywhere refer to Adam as the firstborn. The way the story is presented in Genesis and repeated by Paul, Adam is not “born” at all – he is “formed” by God. This wording doesn’t call up the idea of primogeniture.
And there’s another problem. Ephesus was a leading Hellenic city of the Roman Empire. Romans and Greeks didn’t have a general custom of primogeniture. In Roman law there were no special rules about firstborn sons. The supposed implication would not be perceived by the people Timothy needed to teach.
And yet another problem. If Paul’s reasons in verses 13-14 were seriously intended to support a general rule of male-over-female authority, then that would make Paul look pretty foolish. Timothy knows the Genesis story. Since, as Paul says, Adam was “not deceived”, that means Adam knowingly and deliberately disobeyed God when he ate the forbidden fruit. That’s not much of a recommendation for a general rule of men’s authority, or for men as teachers who stick to God’s word!
It makes much better sense to read Paul’s reasons not as an implied creation ordinance but as an illustration of the danger which he wants to avoid.
Adam was formed first and received God’s command. Before the Woman was formed, he lived in obedience to God. After the Woman was formed, that changed. The Woman was deceived by the serpent’s promise of knowledge, and she transgressed. She not only took the fruit of forbidden knowledge for herself but also persuaded Adam to do the same. See Genesis 3, verses 6 and 17.
What, then, is the analogy with the situation in Ephesus? First Timothy 1 tells us that Paul has already excluded the two male false teachers. The men who remain are not deceived, for in chapter 2 verse 8, Paul instructs them to get on with praying, without anger and disputing. The men no longer need to dispute with the false teachers because Paul has expelled them. But Paul is concerned about what may be done by a deceived woman to a man. The men are in danger from women who have been deceived by the false teaching. Paul doesn’t want one of the rich, deceived women to overpower a man, influencing him to join her in misbehaviour.
For our fifth and final question, we come to one of the strangest verses in the New Testament – 1 Timothy 2 verse 15. In the ESV, Paul says, “Yet she will be saved through childbearing—if they continue in faith and love and holiness, with self-control.”
Q5: What is verse 15 about, and how does it help us to understand the whole passage?
During church history, many different interpretations of this verse have been offered. How can we make sense of it?
In the New Testament gospel, spiritual salvation is through faith in Christ. It’s not through childbearing.
Could Paul be giving a guarantee of physical safety in childbearing? This is unlikely. The New Testament doesn’t promise believers a charmed life, in which nothing bad ever happens. In the first century, childbearing was the most dangerous part of a woman’s life.
It’s worth knowing that in the Greek, in front of the word for childbearing, we have the article: “the”. If we include this in the translation, it becomes “she will be saved through the Childbearing”.
As far as we can tell, the earliest interpretation – by native Greek speakers – understands “the Childbearing” as referring to the birth of Jesus Christ. That is what brings salvation. Remember the angel’s message to Joseph about Mary: “She will bear a son, and you shall call his name Jesus, for he will save his people from their sins.” (Matt. 1:21, ESV. See also Gal. 4:4–5.)
But why would Paul mention the Childbearing and salvation here?
He’s alluding to belief in Artemis of the Ephesians. The goddess was believed to be a supernatural midwife, who particularly assisted women in childbearing. Women who worshipped Artemis would pray to her for safety in childbearing.
Imagine the anxiety of a new convert, a rich young widow. She has been drawn into the church by the message of the gospel. Ideas from the Artemis cult are still in her head. Can she remarry and risk childbearing without the protection of Artemis as midwife? Paul’s message is that she can rely on Christ to save her. If she perseveres in faith and love and holiness, with self-control, she can be certain of final salvation through Christ. This is a reassuring word.
But there is still another issue in this verse. What about the strange switch from singular “she” to plural “they”? – she will be saved through the Childbearing—if they continue in faith and love and holiness, with self-control.
We need to track back to see whom Paul is referring to.
The singular ‘she’ in verse 15 refers to the ‘woman’ of verse 14. This woman is Eve, who taught Adam falsely, and who in Paul’s illustration represents a deceived woman in Ephesus, who is not permitted to teach.
Next, we track back from verse 15, looking for a plural noun which matches ‘they’. We find the matching plural noun in the rich ‘women’ of verses 9 and 10, who are to behave with self-control, not dressing expensively with pearls but instead adorning themselves with good works. These are the same women who in verse 15 need to be advised to live a saved life of faith and love and holiness, with self-control.
By this unusual putting-together of ‘she’ and ‘they’, Paul forcefully brings to Timothy’s attention that he is equating ‘she’ and ‘they’. This means that he’s equating the singular ‘woman’ in verses 11–14 with the plural ‘women’ in verses 9–10. So, the woman who in verses 11–12 must learn in quietness and full submission and not teach and overpower a man is equated with the women whose behaviour is addressed in verses 9–10 and verse 15.
This is a signpost. It confirms that Paul’s instructions about not-teaching are aimed at these particular women, not all women.
Paul’s words are not a general ban applying to all women in all churches.
The general lesson is: if someone in your church is deceived by false teaching, don’t let them teach.
QUESTIONS FOR REFLECTION
- Share your reactions to the idea that ‘I do not permit’ or ‘I am not permitting’ is not suitable wording for stating a general rule against sinful conduct.
- What has been your direct or indirect experience of churches or Christian organisations where Paul’s words in 1 Timothy 2:12 are understood as some kind of general rule against women teaching with authority? Has it been clear exactly what activities women are allowed to do or not allowed to do? Why or why not?
About Andrew Bartlett KC
Andrew Bartlett KC is an International Arbitrator with a BA in Theology. Author of ‘Men and Women in Christ: Fresh Light from the Biblical Texts’ (IVP, 2019) and ‘True Complementarity: Men and Women in Christ’ (IVP, due out in 2026)
More Think Again
Foreword – Why We Still Need to Think Again
Think Again matters because the Bible tells a bigger story than restrictive frameworks allow. From Genesis to Revelation, God calls and sends women alongside…
1 – The Whole Picture
Can we read the Bible better? How to understand and discern the meaning of key texts in light of the overarching metanarrative of scripture that speaks to the…
2 – In the Beginning
Did God design men to lead and women to follow? A deep dive into Genesis 1-3, exploring how the creation narrative depicts co-leadership before the fall and…
3 – Anointed and Appointed
Do we overlook women leaders in the Old Testament? Drawing from Judges, and 2 Kings especially, this piece explores how God intentionally raised up women who…
4 – Too good to be true?
by Revd Dr Canon Sharon Prentis
Is Proverbs 31 the unattainable woman leader? A closer look at the woman depicted in Proverbs 31 and whether she can be held up as a relevant standard for us…
5 – Subversive Influence: Midwives, Daughters and an Orphan Queen
How did biblical women resist evil and confront injustice? Shining a light on bold women who spoke out and whose actions changed Israel’s law and history.…
6 – Hidden Figures
Were women confined to the margins of Jesus’ story? Delving into the Gospels, this piece examines how Jesus deliberately drew women in from the margins and…
7 – Female Preacher
How did Jesus release women to communicate His message? An expansive look at some of the women Jesus chose to be his spokespeople. Covering John 4, John 20,…
8 – Misogynist or Misrepresented?
What did the Apostle Paul really think about women? Romans 16, Acts 18 — Paul’s perspective on Christian ministry, drawing attention to women ministers in New…
9 – Headship & Authority
What does 1 Corinthians 11 teach about headship and authority? Understanding the cultural context, unpacking the concept of headship and discovering how Paul…
10 – Sit down and shut up!
Does the Bible really tell women to be quiet and submissive? 1 Corinthians 14 — Breaking down this key and often controversial verse, “women should remain…
12 – Off Limits
Are there limits on the spiritual gifts and callings women can receive? How prophecy, preaching, and leadership are for all believers, without restriction,…
13 – A new beginning
How are women and men a vital part of God’s restoration project? Considering how the final chapters of Scripture paint a prophetic picture of God’s restored…
More Think Again
Foreword – Why We Still Need to Think Again
Think Again matters because the Bible tells a bigger story than restrictive frameworks allow. From Genesis to Revelation, God calls and sends women alongside…
1 – The Whole Picture
Can we read the Bible better? How to understand and discern the meaning of key texts in light of the overarching metanarrative of scripture that speaks to the…
2 – In the Beginning
Did God design men to lead and women to follow? A deep dive into Genesis 1-3, exploring how the creation narrative depicts co-leadership before the fall and…
3 – Anointed and Appointed
Do we overlook women leaders in the Old Testament? Drawing from Judges, and 2 Kings especially, this piece explores how God intentionally raised up women who…
4 – Too good to be true?
by Revd Dr Canon Sharon Prentis
Is Proverbs 31 the unattainable woman leader? A closer look at the woman depicted in Proverbs 31 and whether she can be held up as a relevant standard for us…
5 – Subversive Influence: Midwives, Daughters and an Orphan Queen
How did biblical women resist evil and confront injustice? Shining a light on bold women who spoke out and whose actions changed Israel’s law and history.…
6 – Hidden Figures
Were women confined to the margins of Jesus’ story? Delving into the Gospels, this piece examines how Jesus deliberately drew women in from the margins and…
7 – Female Preacher
How did Jesus release women to communicate His message? An expansive look at some of the women Jesus chose to be his spokespeople. Covering John 4, John 20,…
8 – Misogynist or Misrepresented?
What did the Apostle Paul really think about women? Romans 16, Acts 18 — Paul’s perspective on Christian ministry, drawing attention to women ministers in New…
9 – Headship & Authority
What does 1 Corinthians 11 teach about headship and authority? Understanding the cultural context, unpacking the concept of headship and discovering how Paul…
10 – Sit down and shut up!
Does the Bible really tell women to be quiet and submissive? 1 Corinthians 14 — Breaking down this key and often controversial verse, “women should remain…
12 – Off Limits
Are there limits on the spiritual gifts and callings women can receive? How prophecy, preaching, and leadership are for all believers, without restriction,…
13 – A new beginning
How are women and men a vital part of God’s restoration project? Considering how the final chapters of Scripture paint a prophetic picture of God’s restored…


